Sometimes it is not about who is right or wrong, but about what is lawful. Motorists will soon say goodbye to traffic stops in New York, as a new proposed Senate Bill could make roads quite different as of this date. The new bill has led to much contradiction, especially for those trying to determine what is right and what is wrong. However, in the eyes of the law, this new Senate Bill will only cause more problems than it will solve.
This new Senate Bill said goodbye to traffic stops in New York
This Albany proposal is causing quite a stir, especially among top law enforcement officials. They refer to Senate Bill S3662A as the “most dangerous” and “craziest” ever seen. The proposed bill working its way through the New York state legislature would ban police officers from running traffic stops for minor violations to limit “unnecessary” stops and further “racial equity and public safety.”
This means officers will no longer be allowed to pull motorists over or search their vehicles for countless violations, which include a busted taillight, expired vehicle registration tags, too much window tint, or if the smell of marijuana is detected.
If approved, the bill would start being enforced from January 1 of the following year.
Certain events led to the proposed Senate Bill
According to the bill, racial minorities in the state account for the majority of arrests and traffic stops. Those in support of the bill insisted that the bill is a crucial step in the promotion of racial equity and to prevent needless police encounters, especially in Nassau. The county is currently facing an active lawsuit against its police, who allegedly “acted with racial bias” during traffic stops.
The county’s population consists of less than 30% black and Latino residents combined, but according to police data, they account for 61% of arrests, 50% of traffic stops, 60% of field interviews, and 69% of pat-downs. It also states that white drivers, on average, receive 1.3 tickets per stop compared to two tickets for black drivers and 2.1 for Latino drivers.
Many people from this county are opposing the new rule
According to a report by the Nassau County Executive, Bruce Blakeman, it is “ridiculous” to insist that racial bias occurs during policing during traffic stops, because officers are usually unaware of the driver’s race before making a stop.
It’s just a bizarre argument, it’s pro-criminal. It doesn’t matter what race you are. If you’re breaking the law, then you’re breaking the law.” – Blakeman.
Nassau Police Commissioner, Patrick Ryder, argues that roads will become unsafe if officers no longer have the power to enforce the law for low-level infractions such as busted lights and/or expired registrations. Anne Donnely, the county’s district attorney, concurs that the bill will only enable people to get away with breaking the law, especially in Nassau.
A traffic stop not only protects the roads against minor violations but may also assist in major crimes. In 1993, serial killer Joel Rifkin, who murdered at least 17 people, was stopped due to a missing license plate on the rear of his tan Mazda pickup truck, which contained a body in the trunk, and was finally arrested.
We have to agree with Nassau District Attorney Anne Donnely that these traffic stops are not only legitimate but also important. Imagine how many crimes criminals can get away with if police officers are prohibited from pulling them over, even just to check that they have the new driver’s license. The new proposed bill has been reviewed by the Senate Committee and transferred to the Transportation Committee for review. To stay up to date with the latest status of Senate Bill S3662A, follow the Senate Bill S3662A in the New York State Senate link.