The Elwha River had become one of the great American comeback stories.
Two dams came down, the river ran free again, and salmon returned to gravel they had not reached in nearly a century.
Indian Creek was part of that recovery.
On a July morning last year, a fuel tanker failed to negotiate a turn on Highway 101 west of Port Angeles and went down the embankment into the creek.
What happens to restored salmon habitat when a highway crosses it is the question the creek answered almost at once.
What spilled fuel does to gravel a salmon just found
Gasoline is acutely toxic to fish, and it does not behave like a heavy oil slick. Much of it evaporates, part of it dissolves and moves with the current, and some of it works down among the cobbles into the saturated gravel beneath and beside the channel, where eggs incubate and small fish and lamprey shelter. Trustees recorded impacts to both the surface water and that subsurface zone in Indian Creek and in part of the Elwha River.
That is why responders later turned to sparging, agitating the streambed to release fuel trapped under rocks and debris so sorbent materials could pick it up. A fish and invertebrate die off was observed in the creek and along the Elwha downstream of the confluence almost immediately after the discharge.
The fish caught in that plume were not ordinary residents of an ordinary stream. They were part of a population that had been able to reach that water for little more than a decade, in gravel that was still being colonized.
The curve, the drop and how the tanker came to rest in the water
By the State Patrol’s account, the fuel truck failed to negotiate a turn on Highway 101, veered off the road and careened down an embankment before landing upside down in Indian Creek. It was a dual trailer rig: one trailer carried an estimated 3,900 gallons of diesel and the second held up to 6,000 gallons of gasoline.
What reached the water was overwhelmingly the lighter fuel. About 2,798 gallons of gasoline and 172 gallons of diesel were released, just under 3,000 gallons in all, which matches the rough figure responders were using on the first day.
Crews were on scene within hours and put containment boom and sorbent materials in the water downstream. The overturned tanker was lifted out early the following morning, ending the risk of further release, but the fuel already in the creek was well down the drainage by then.
What the count confirmed and how it was tallied
Wildlife teams walked the affected reach once the tanker was clear. Dead organisms collected included lamprey, coho salmon, federally listed salmonids such as Chinook, steelhead and bull trout, along with sculpin, crayfish and other bottom dwelling invertebrates.
The state’s confirmed fish kill reached more than 2,130 while wildlife monitoring was still under way. A hand tally in moving water is a floor rather than a total, since carcasses wash out, get eaten or lodge under banks. The tribe’s natural resources director described hundreds, and possibly thousands, of juvenile salmon, sculpin and lamprey dying in the fuel’s wake.
State accounts describe the creek as the Lower Elwha Klallam Tribe sees it: a living symbol of restoration, home to returning salmon and part of a broader healing effort years in the making. The tribe sat in the unified command alongside county, state and federal agencies and the responsible party.
A creek that carries more history than most
Indian Creek sits inside the Elwha watershed, where the removal of two dams was the largest project of its kind in the country at the time. On the Elwha, the lower dam had blocked migrating fish since 1913, and after it came down biologists documented anadromous Chinook spawning in Indian Creek in 2013. That record for dam removal has since passed to the Klamath River, where four dams came out by the end of last year.
Recovery on this river has been measured in decades rather than seasons, with biologists projecting 20 to 30 years for the runs to rebuild. The creek also feeds the Elwha upstream of the intake that supplies Port Angeles, a city of 20,000 residents. The city shut down its water treatment operations within hours of the crash, issued a do not drink order two days later, and lifted it that same evening after testing showed the supply had not been contaminated.
That the fuel plume and the municipal intake shared one small watershed made a few thousand gallons a larger event than the volume alone suggests.
What comes next and what the gap between cleanup and recovery really is
Emergency response at Indian Creek concluded and the incident moved into environmental recovery and monitoring. Tribal, state and federal trustees opened a natural resource damage assessment to evaluate long term impacts and determine restoration needs, a process that can run for years when listed species are involved.
For the Lower Elwha Klallam Tribe, salmon in that creek are not only an ecological indicator but a relationship with the land that the dam removals were partly meant to restore. The assessment records that the discharge may have harmed cultural uses and other services those resources provide, which names something a fish survey cannot count.
The gravel in Indian Creek will flush clean over time and the invertebrate population will rebuild. What is harder to replace is the year class that never reached the spawning beds, and the gaps those absences leave in a population still finding its footing. You can see how long that ledger stays open in the record of infrastructure crossing fragile waterways, where the real numbers arrive long after the booms come up.
Indian Creek will keep running. The salmon were there before the highway, and the evidence from the Elwha suggests they will keep pushing upstream. But the curve on Highway 101 has not moved, and neither has the creek bed waiting at the bottom of it.
Read the whole thing?
Get the week's signal, not the noise
Our sharpest reporting on energy, climate and nature — free, once a week.
