A river barrier is expected to work by being heavy.
The bigger and heavier it is, the more it should hold back.
In Québec, heavy floating barriers meant to stop river ice have done the opposite. Too much ice is passing over them.
Could smaller barriers do a better job?
Ice barriers on a Québec river
Hydro-Québec runs hydroelectric stations on rivers across the province.
Three of the big ones are the Beauharnois generating station, the Carillon hydroelectric station and the Chute Bell station.
Carillon stands on the Ottawa River, which marks much of the border between Québec and Ontario. Beauharnois stands on the St. Lawrence River, southwest of Montréal.
These stations are built to turn flowing water into electricity. The water passes through the turbines of each station, which drive their generators.
Their work depends on water that can move freely. In winter, this cannot be taken for granted.
The main winter threat is frazil ice. It forms in cold, flowing water as a mass of tiny ice crystals, or river slush.
Frazil appears when moving water cools slightly below freezing. This is why it can form in a river that is still moving.
To control the buildup of frazil, hydroelectric stations use ice booms. These are floating barriers made of pontoons.
In Québec, the existing booms were failing.
They were not able to provide enough resistance and during Spring, too much ice passed over them.
A new concept design was therefore called in for three new safety booms.
Two would sit upstream and downstream of Carillon, and one downstream of Chute Bell.
What the old booms were made of
Booms alone are not the complete answer to frazil. In Iceland, a concrete boom 13 feet deep keeps frazil out of a power canal at Hrauneyjafoss.
Even there, frazil can still build up at the trash racks. A boom reduces the problem but does not remove it.
The old pontoon barriers were double pontoons, made from an old floating platform.
They also had to be handled every year. Crews removed them and stored them for the navigation season.
So the Québec stations tested new booms in the field. The aim was to prove a better ice resistance capacity than the old ones.
The new design used cylindrical steel pontoons.
They were not bigger than before. But they worked a lot better.
Why smaller worked better
The new pontoons installed are now smaller and more buoyant.
Smaller may seem controversial when it comes to a barrier, but in this case, buoyancy was more important.
Buoyancy matters the most because a boom that sits low in the water can be overrun. Ice then rides over the barrier instead of stopping against it.
In plain terms, size alone had not protected the stations.
The new cylindrical pontoons are also easier to handle and store. Observations during the winter of 2011–12 showed a higher ice resistance capacity than the old ones.
Future plans could call for replacing all the pontoon barriers with steel cylinders of the same design, if these hold for years to come.
Hydro dams can be essential to communities like this one, so keeping them in operation is important.
So can a smaller barrier be more useful for hydro dams?
Geniglace shows it can, however, the evidence is thin.
It has only been one winter of observation, so more data will be needed to reach a firm conclusion. If this design shows success in the following winters, then it could be the new standard for ice barriers. Until then, it is a promising lead, but not yet a fully proven solution.
Other clean energy systems like this one are also being tested to see if they can withstand ice.
Read the whole thing?
Get the week's signal, not the noise
Our sharpest reporting on energy, climate and nature — free, once a week.